How to Get the Best Claim Payout from Your Mexican Car Insurance Policy
The Problem Most Travelers Never Hear About
Most people heading to Mexico have no idea how the insurance company decides what their car was worth if it’s stolen or totaled.
They just assume it’ll be the same as back in the U.S. — based on U.S. Kelley Blue Book or N.A.D.A. retail values. But most Mexican insurers don’t use those. Instead, they rely on Mexico’s own valuation guides, which typically list your car’s worth 30–40% lower. Some insurers even blend them together using the lowest U.S. values like wholesale combined with Mexico based guides.
They just assume it’ll be the same as back in the U.S. — based on U.S. Kelley Blue Book or N.A.D.A. retail values. But most Mexican insurers don’t use those. Instead, they rely on Mexico’s own valuation guides, which typically list your car’s worth 30–40% lower. Some insurers even blend them together using the lowest U.S. values like wholesale combined with Mexico based guides.
The result? You could end up with half the payout you expected and still owe the bank for a car you no longer have.
👉 At Mexican Insurance Store, we partner with Global A+ rated top-tier Mexican car insurers (CHUBB, HDI & MAPFRE) who all base payouts on U.S. Kelley Blue Book or N.A.D.A. (JD Power) retail values, not Mexico’s much lower-valuation guides like Libro Azul or Guía EBC.
This one recommendation could save you thousands of dollars if the worst happens and it’s the most reliable way we’ve found to make sure clients get the highest payout possible.
How Lower Valuations Leave You Short
Sadly, most lower-tier Mexican insurers rely on local Mexico based guides like Libro Azul or Guía EBC, which typically list values 30–40% below U.S. KBB retail. Some even mix these with the lowest U.S. categories, like wholesale.
That means if your car is stolen or totaled, you could end up with far less than you expect.
I’ve seen far too many stories like these:
A $35,000 Toyota Tacoma was stolen — payout was only $18,000
A $28,000 SUV — payout came back $14,000
A $50,000 RV — payout was under $30,000
A $35,000 Toyota Tacoma was stolen — payout was only $18,000
A $28,000 SUV — payout came back $14,000
A $50,000 RV — payout was under $30,000
Imagine trying to pay off a U.S. loan with only half the money you thought you’d get. Sadly, it happens more often than most travelers realize.
The Single Most Important Question to Ask
Before you buy, ask:
“How will my car be valued if it’s stolen or totaled?”
If the answer is “market value” or “whatever it’s worth at the time,” push harder.
We all know each insurer uses Actual Cash Value, but from what guide?
Ask if the insurer uses Mexico valuation guides or if the insurer blends Mexico guides with KBB guide in order to justify a lower value payout.
If so, you could easily be offered far less than it’s worth in the United States.
And if your broker can’t give you a straight answer? It’s time to find one who can.
Why Some People Say Mexican Insurance Doesn’t Pay
It’s not that insurance in Mexico doesn’t work — it’s that many people unknowingly pick policies that pay far less because of how vehicles their are valued.
That’s why at Mexican Insurance Store, we only partner with insurers who specifically use U.S. Kelley Blue Book or N.A.D.A. (JD Power) retail values. It’s the most reliable way we’ve found to make sure clients get the highest payout possible.
In other words, the reason to choose a top-tier A+ Rated insurer is because you are much more likely to get what you pay for.
Why Some Brokers Push Lower-Priced Policies
You’ll often hear brokers say:
“The price is lower.
Are they a good company? Well, they’re a very big company.”
And that’s usually where it ends.
Being a big company doesn’t guarantee how they’ll value your car if it’s stolen or totaled.
Example: Qualitas insurance company and most other local Mexico insurers still rely on Mexico’s own valuation guides or blend them with the lowest U.S. KBB categories like wholesale.
That’s why so many people end up with payouts thousands less than they expected.
The real question isn’t “Are they big?” — it’s:
“How will they calculate your payout if your car is stolen or totaled?”
Because that’s what decides if you walk away whole — or still owe thousands on a car that’s long gone.
What? They Can’t Do That! — The Fine Print That Trips People Up
Most people just hear, “Don’t worry, you’re fully covered.” But buried in lower-tier policies is language like this (common with Qualitas and most other lower-tier or unrated carriers):
“La indemnización será conforme al valor comercial del vehículo determinado por el asegurador al momento del siniestro.”
Translation:
“The settlement will be based on the commercial value of the vehicle as determined by the insurer at the time of the loss.”
That means the insurance company decides what your car was worth after the fact, using whatever guide they choose.
Paying a Little More Now Can Protect You a Lot More Later
The cost difference in coverage is small. The protection difference? Huge.
Most top insurers let you repair your vehicle back in the U.S., making things simpler when you need it most.
It’s Not Just About The Money Either— It’s About Your Freedom Too!
Few realize that in Mexico, after a serious accident, you could be detained until the other party is satisfied or your insurer pays up.
A judge can even hold you for up to 72 hours, even if your insurance already approved medical bills.
That’s not something you want to handle with a lower-tier insurer who may not have the staff to provide good service.
Bottom Line
I’ve spent years helping people figure this out — often after it’s too late. Don’t just shop for the lowest price.
Make sure your policy is tied to U.S. valuation standards, so you’re not left paying off a car that’s long gone.
Friendly Disclaimer
This article is based on public information, real-world claim stories, common practices, and my own observations.
It’s meant for general guidance only, not personal insurance advice. Every insurer and claim is different. Always review your actual policy before you buy.
It’s meant for general guidance only, not personal insurance advice. Every insurer and claim is different. Always review your actual policy before you buy.
Best Mexico Insurance News, Information, Rate Guide and Reviews – Save Time, Money, and Frustration
